French Labour Law

Economic Dismissal in France: A Turnover Drop Is Not Enough

Written by DAIRIA Law's AI. It has not been checked claim by claim against official sources by an independent AI. DAIRIA Avocats takes editorial responsibility.

DAIRIA Law · Published · 6 min

Economic Dismissal in France: Why a Drop in Turnover Is No Longer Enough on Its Own

Since 2016, the French Labour Code has given employers what looked like an objective test for an economic dismissal (licenciement pour motif économique): a fall in orders or turnover over a set number of consecutive quarters, depending on headcount. Many international groups read it as a safe harbour. On 7 October 2026 the Cour de cassation, France’s highest civil court, made clear that it is not. Even when the drop is established over the statutory period, the judge must still check, on all the evidence, that the change is significant enough to show genuine economic difficulties (Cass. soc., 7 October 2026, No. 25-10.107, joined with Nos. 25-10.108, 25-11.252 and 25-11.253, published in the Bulletin).

This article explains the statutory test, what the court decided, and how to build an economic file that will hold up.

The Statutory Test: Quarters by Headcount

Article L. 1233-3 of the French Labour Code defines economic difficulties as a significant change in at least one economic indicator, such as a fall in orders or turnover, operating losses, or a deterioration in cash flow or gross operating surplus, or any other element capable of showing those difficulties.

For orders and turnover, the text sets a minimum duration, compared with the same period of the previous year:

HeadcountMinimum duration of the drop
Fewer than 11 employeesOne quarter
11 to 49 employeesTwo consecutive quarters
50 to 299 employeesThree consecutive quarters
300 employees or moreFour consecutive quarters

Economic difficulties are only one of the possible grounds. The same article also covers technological change, a reorganisation needed to safeguard competitiveness and the cessation of activity.

What the Court Decided on 7 October 2026

The employer was an asset-management company with around thirty employees, which put it in the two-quarter bracket. It notified two analysts of the economic grounds for their dismissal in June 2020. Both accepted the contrat de sécurisation professionnelle (CSP), the outplacement scheme whose acceptance terminates the contract while leaving the economic ground open to challenge.

The company relied on a fall in turnover in the first two quarters of 2020 compared with 2019. The Paris Court of Appeal accepted that the fall existed, but held that it was not a significant, serious and lasting change. The two quarters matched the Covid-19 lockdown, which had caused a sudden and largely cyclical dip in management fees from March 2020, followed by a recovery. The court also relied on statements made by the company’s founding partner at the time of the dismissals about the funds catching up with the market, and on the absence of evidence on management fees after October 2020 and on performance fees, the second component of turnover named in the employer’s own letter.

The dismissals were held to lack a real and serious cause, and the employer was ordered to pay damages and to reimburse unemployment benefits to France Travail up to six months.

The employer argued before the Cour de cassation that two quarters of decline were, by definition, enough. The court disagreed. Reading Article L. 1233-3 “in the light of the parliamentary debates”, it held that even where the drop in turnover or orders over the statutory period is established, the judge must still verify, on all the evidence in the file, that the change is significant enough to characterise economic difficulties justifying the dismissal. The appeal was dismissed.

What This Means for Employers

The quarter count is a floor, not a safe harbour. Meeting the duration threshold gets you through the door. It does not end the discussion.

Context counts. A sudden, temporary dip followed by a recovery may be treated as cyclical rather than as economic difficulty. The judge looks at the whole trajectory, including what happened shortly after the dismissal.

Your own words will be read. Public statements by management, investor letters and internal communications made at the same time can be produced by employees and weighed against the economic file.

Every component of turnover must be documented. If your notification letter says turnover has two components, be ready to prove both.

Building an Economic File That Holds Up

  1. Identify the bracket from your headcount and check the drop over the right number of consecutive quarters, compared with the same quarters of the previous year.
  2. Go beyond the headline figure. Combine turnover with other indicators named by the text where relevant: operating losses, cash flow, gross operating surplus.
  3. Explain why the drop is not a blip. Document the market, the order book and the outlook at the date of the dismissal.
  4. Align communications. Make sure management statements made at the same time do not contradict the economic case.
  5. Keep the evidence complete and certified where possible, and cover every revenue stream mentioned in the letter.
  6. Do not neglect the rest of the procedure. Redeployment (reclassement) obligations, the CSP offer and the pre-dismissal steps remain separate grounds of challenge. See our guide to the pre-dismissal interview and our foreign employer’s guide to dismissing an employee in France.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are two quarters of falling turnover enough for an economic dismissal in a company of 11 to 49 employees?

Not on their own. Two consecutive quarters is the minimum duration set by Article L. 1233-3 for that headcount, but the Cour de cassation held on 7 October 2026 (No. 25-10.107) that the judge must still check, on all the evidence, that the change is significant enough to show economic difficulties.

Can a judge take into account a recovery after the dismissal?

In this case the appeal court relied on the fact that management fees had bounced back after the lockdown and that the company had not produced figures after October 2020. The Cour de cassation approved its conclusion that the difficulties were not sufficiently established.

What happens if the economic ground is rejected?

The dismissal is without real and serious cause. The employer then owes damages within the statutory scale of Article L. 1235-3 and, in this case, was also ordered to reimburse unemployment benefits to France Travail up to six months (Article L. 1235-4).

Does accepting the CSP prevent the employee from challenging the dismissal?

No. In this case both employees had accepted the CSP and still challenged, successfully, the economic ground.


Planning a restructuring in France? DAIRIA Law helps international employers test the economic case before the first letter goes out and build a file that answers the questions a French judge will ask. Contact DAIRIA Law.

French version of our weekly letter: sofianecoly.substack.com.

Get the newsletter

Sofiane Coly’s letter. He is a lawyer and the founder of DAIRIA Avocats. The letter is in French: French employment law and payroll, explained for employers, with the sources. Free, and published on Substack.

Subscribe on Substack

Sign-up and unsubscribe are handled on Substack. This site does not collect your email address for the letter. Privacy policy.

YouTube · DAIRIA AVOCATS

Latest video

Gross misconduct: the one-month deadline sick leave does not suspend (video in French)